Jordan, Dashel, and Seth met one fateful night in 2005, just a few days before Christmas, on a small island in the Puget Sound. At a intimate house show, where each's band was to play. Jordan, in the newly formed and not yet named Yes, Oh Yes, Seth in the newly formed The Casual Lust, and Dashel, performing solo through a impressively rigged boombox... It would be nearly three years before the three would come together once again at a pizza party to form the band A Million Years Ago.